November 5, 2026
"These aren't revolutionary changes," State Parks administrator Alan Carpenter told Honolulu Civil Beat in May, a few weeks before the Maui Planning Commission took up the plan for Mākena State Park. "We're just talking about the improvement of the existing experience for those who already come and visit."
Flyers and social media posts that month warned that access to Oneloa, Big Beach, could soon be restricted. The plan the commission approved in July does something quieter. It brings water service into a 164.4-acre park whose official listing still says "No drinking water available." It also leaves out the gates, reservations and shuttles that people feared would come with it. The pipes are the real change. Most of what the plan does to the parking lots is put lines on dirt that people already park on.
On July 14, the commission voted 6–1 for a Special Management Area permit. The permit allows the Department of Land and Natural Resources' Division of State Parks to build two restrooms with showers and to expand parking across the park's 1.5 miles of coastline, which take in Oneloa, Oneʻuli or Black Sand Beach, and Puʻu Ōlaʻi, the cinder cone above Little Beach, as The Maui News reported. The commission had deferred the item at its June 23 meeting so the state could answer its questions in writing.
| At the park today | Under the approved plan | |
|---|---|---|
| Restrooms | Portable toilets at the north and south lots | Two comfort stations with permanent restrooms |
| Showers | None | Showers at the comfort stations |
| Drinking water | None available | Water service, including a bottle-filling station |
| Parking | 238 spaces, mostly on dirt | 276 spaces, mostly on pervious surfaces, with limited paved ADA stalls |
| Resident entry and parking | Free with Hawaiʻi ID | Unchanged |
| Reservations or shuttles | None | None planned |
Three of the four rows that describe something new, the restrooms, showers and drinking water, depend on running water.
The plan brings water service into the park for toilets, sinks, showers and a bottle-filling station. Two new service lines will tap the existing 12-inch water line along the road, according to the meeting record kept by Akakū's Maui County issue tracker. Wastewater will not go into the ground at the beach. It will collect in underground tanks, 13,000 gallons at the north site and 7,000 at the south, and get trucked away for treatment. Water from the outdoor showers will drain through a swale into a grass basin. In June, commissioners also asked the state whether it had an agreement to connect to a nearby resort's wastewater treatment plant.
The June testimony split along the same line. One speaker backed permanent restrooms, saying people now leave toilet paper in the bushes. Another worried about new showers and bathrooms drawing water while the island is in drought. Carpenter told Civil Beat that most of the hundreds of community members surveyed between about 2013 and 2020 supported permanent restrooms and showers, and that "the overarching sentiment was that they didn't want it to change much."
That sentiment shapes how much the parking changes.
The first version of the plan would have grown paved parking from 97 stalls to 235. That version is gone. The revised plan Carpenter submitted on July 14 puts more of the parking on pervious surfaces to cut rain runoff and adds only enough paved stalls to meet the Americans with Disabilities Act. Counting all spaces, paved or not, the state told the commission that parking would grow from 238 to 276, about 13 percent.
Carpenter described the main parking change to Civil Beat as paving and marking stalls in dirt areas already used for parking. Critics quoted in the same article said marked stalls could fit fewer cars into the unpaved areas than fit there now, and that the community feedback behind the plan was collected before the pandemic and the 2023 wildfires. State Parks also said it will keep working with the fire department to fix tight spots in the lot.
Maui Tomorrow executive director Albert Perez called the shift to pervious surfaces "a victory," The Maui News reported, though he still opposes the comfort stations and showers.
The approved plan does not add any of the access controls that circulated in May. The state told the commission the plan includes:
That sets Mākena apart from Waiʻānapanapa State Park in East Maui, Diamond Head on Oʻahu and Hāʻena on Kauaʻi. Those three were the reservation-based parks that Civil Beat said worried critics.
The fee structure stays where it is. According to the DLNR park page, Hawaiʻi residents enter and park free with a Hawaiʻi driver's license or state ID. Nonresidents pay $5 per person to enter and $10 per noncommercial vehicle to park, and children 3 and under are free. Nonresidents can pay at the kiosks or online through ParkMobile. Paid parking started in the first week of January 2020, when DLNR installed three electronic pay stations. In June, the state apologized to the commission for installing two booths and three pay stations without Special Management Area approval, and the permit now covers them.
One idea some testifiers raised, parking set aside only for residents, did not make it into the plan. A State Parks lawyer told the commission on July 14 that resident-only parking would likely be found unconstitutional, according to Akakū's record of the meeting.
The new buildings also brought the plan's sharpest debate, which was about light. Hawaiʻi Wildlife Fund told the commission that Mākena is the most successful turtle nesting beach the group monitors on Maui. After consulting the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, State Parks cut the exterior lights at each comfort station from six to one. That single fixture is shielded, points down, sits recessed under the roofline and faces away from the shoreline. All interior and exterior lights run on timers and shut off at 8 p.m., which gives staff about an hour to clean after the park closes at 7. The division said it could reduce the lighting further or remove it if it proves unnecessary.
Commissioner Mark Deakos cast the only vote against. He told The Maui News:
"This is the last beach that still has dark skies. I wouldn't go and put a comfort station in some remote beach in Lanai or Molokai because that's just cracking the door open for more impact, and I think that's what we're doing here with this."
Hannah Bernard, executive director of Hawaiʻi Wildlife Fund, told The Maui News she would have preferred no lighting at all. She noted that nesting can happen right at sunset and that hatchlings can emerge at any hour, and said the group will keep monitoring the project. DLNR's Division of Aquatic Resources puts hawksbill nesting season in Hawaiʻi at May through December, so this season runs for several more weeks.
The timeline explains why the plan looks the way it does:
No construction start date, contract award or closure schedule has been announced since the July vote. Carpenter told Civil Beat in May that he hoped construction would begin as soon as the county approved the plan, adding that "the designs have been done forever." Because years have passed since the money was approved, the project's earlier estimate of roughly $2.1 million has risen substantially, and so has the time Carpenter expects construction to take. The first phase is the comfort station and parking work near the north entrance.
The commission also required a carrying-capacity study of the ecological, environmental and physical effects of park activity. The Maui News reported the deadline as July 31, 2028. Akakū's meeting tracker records it as July 31, 2029. Either way, that study is where any future debate over visitor limits would begin.
For now the park runs on its usual schedule. DLNR's October 23 notice says all Maui and Molokaʻi state parks have reopened after Hurricanes Lowell and Nolo, apart from Polipoli and Waiʻānapanapa. Oneloa and Oneʻuli are open daily from 5 a.m. to 7 p.m. Puʻu Ōlaʻi closes at 4 p.m. on Saturdays and Sundays.
Many South Maui owners count a quick drive to Big Beach as part of the reason they chose Wailea or Mākena. If you are weighing a home on this stretch of coast, or wondering how projects like this one figure into a property's value, Renee Amey is glad to talk through what she sees across Maui. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
From West Maui luxury estates to new construction across the island, Renee Amey leverages 20+ years of proven market expertise to turn your Maui real estate goals into reality.